the effects of endotracheal tube and i-gel® supraglottic airway device on respiratory impedance: a prospective observational study

background the forced oscillation technique (fot) is a non-invasive means of measuring respiratory resistance and reactance. we tested our hypothesis that endotracheal intubation would cause more substantial preoperative increases in fot parameters than a supraglottic airway device (sgd). methods forty patients requiring general anesthesia and mechanical ventilation for transurethral bladder tumor resection underwent spirometry the day before surgery. forced oscillation was measured using a mostgraph-01 device the day before surgery and immediately after removal of the airway adjunct. changes in respiratory resistance and reactance were compared between those intubated and those who used sgd. results the trachea was intubated in 23 patients and sgd was used in the remaining 17 patients. both airway adjuncts caused significant increases in preoperative respiratory resistance and reactance; however, the magnitude of the changes was significantly greater in the intubated patients. conclusions the sgd appears to cause less pulmonary injury than tracheal intubation. further study is needed to illuminate the influence of mechanical ventilation, and longer-term consequences and clinical significance of the changes we found in this study. spontaneous ventilation through an sgd may be preferable in patients with severe respiratory disease.